Tuesday, October 6, 2015

Language

Language  Blog  


My experience conducting a 15 minute conversation without being able to use any (words, writing or ASL.) This was one of the most difficult things to do, it was not a conversation that I could have without being able to use body language, pointing , hand signals and gestures. I decided to use my husband as the subject for my nonverbal conversation.  I decided to talk about how our day was a normal conversation that we have everyday to just discuss our day and unwind. It was very hard to initiate a conversation while trying to remember  not to talk, I almost felt like we where playing a game of  charades.  I decided the best way to get through this was by using gestures and pointing to objects around me to que him into what I was referring to. 
 once he understood a portion of the conversation I would move my hands motioning him to continue along those lines feeding me words or phrase until he almost guessing  the right thing. 
  This conversation continued far beyond 15 minutes and was not a conversation that I was able to control. I almost felt powerless and frustrated without being able to express myself like I really wanted and when my husband came close but was not guessing the right thing I had to try not to let the frustration take over so that I could think of more ways to try to get him to understand. there was no balance at all in this conversation because it was basically a guessing game. I would make a hand movement then point jump up and down and he would try to piece it all together.  

If this was a conversation where I was from a different culture that did not use spoken language this would have been a lot more challenging because the way that I used objects and body language would not have been something I would have known to do.  I think that this would have been a prime example of a Neanderthal trying to communicate with a modern day human.

  Language and words and the way we express ourselves come from our generation and current time of trends.  we use slang words and a lot of acronyms that another culture may not understand. we tend to take for granted that people just understand or get what we are trying to relate because we do this everyday but a person that is not from our culture and has no idea what we are trying to say would be very difficult to conduct a useful conversation.  

This experiment was a lot easier using words without anything else was not as hard until I realized ho much I use my hands to gesture. I found myself trying to smile and use verbal ques which where against the rules for the assignment. I was able to get my thoughts and words across but it was very hard to understand the response I was getting because I couldn't express a tone or a feeling in what I was saying. without using facial expressions nor changing  my tome to express myself or emphasizes a word to create expression was rough.  

when we read a persons body language it allows us to communicate more than our actual words . we use our facial expression, tone of voice how close we are to the other person our  eye contact and even when we don’t say anything at all says a lot. When we communicate and have a conversation our mouth and body sometimes can relay to different messages.  The way we listen and look and how we react to another persons conversation weather we care or not our nonverbal signals should match our words that we are saying.  
being able to read and understand body language is a very important quality to posses. It allows us to better understand a person and understanding social cues whether they are positive or negative will give us great insight when communicating with others.  Body language can also help use to determine how another person is feeling if what they are saying is truthful or not and if they may just be having a bad day.  

There are many people whom have problems interrupting body language  these people can be from different cultures or diverse backgrounds where different gestures have different meanings. some cultures have gender driven gestures where you may need to use more gestures when talking to a man or a women to show a form of respect.  For instance when you greet in America we use standard greetings such as " Hello, my name is" and we handshake to say hello. In japan people bow when they first meet. In Italy people kiss cheeks.  learning when the appropriate body langue and gesture is appropriate is a great way to become a better communicator. 

1 comment:

  1. Good description of your part 1 experiment, including the issue of power and control in the conversation.

    "I think that this would have been a prime example of a Neanderthal trying to communicate with a modern day human."

    I agree. That was partly what I had in mind when I created this experiment, to have students imagine that situation in our evolutionary history when a speaking H. sapien population met a population of neanderthals who have a more limited ability to speak. Thank you for making that connection.

    Can you discuss the issue of communicating complex ideas? Is it possible do this without symbolic language?

    With regard to your description on part 2, you explore your own experiences but you don't discuss the response from your partner. That is often the most interesting part of this experiment, with some of them actually getting angry and walking out of the room.

    Can you identify specific information that body language communicates? It certainly provides information on emotion but it goes far beyond that. Humans actually use body language as a lie detector. If your words don't match your body language, a warning flag goes up in the head of the person you are talking to, suggesting that what you said was not true. This can be used benignly to figure out if a friend is more upset than they are letting on so you can help them, or it can be used to evaluate the honesty of a stranger you have just met. Can you trust them? Does their body language match their promise to help you? If you lend them money, will they repay it?

    "Body language can also help use to determine how another person is feeling if what they are saying is truthful or not..."

    You come very close to a key point here. How could it benefit your survival and reproductive success if you couldn't discern whether or not a person was lying to you? Would your reproductive success be better or worse compared to a person who could detect liars by reading body language?

    I agree that because different cultures use different systems of body language, those coming to a new country may not be able to read the body language of native people there. It is also a situation where it may be best to not read body language, since you would be getting misleading information. Good discussion on this.

    ReplyDelete